Food, running and culture: one refugee’s story

Food, running and culture: one refugee’s story

As told to Hillary Leung and Tegan Smyth. Words by Tegan Smyth.

 Joseph* is a refugee from a country in Africa that is currently embroiled in sectarian violence. He spoke to us about his daily life as a refugee as well as sharing a treasured recipe from home.

 

Could you tell us a little about the food you cooked today?

Today I cooked beef with tomato sauce, onion, garlic and semolina – with some rice on the side. For dessert, we have fresh mango. I think it is a nice dish for people to eat.

 

What do you call the semolina meal in your culture? I know in some places it is called ugali or fufu.

In my country, we call it “kosa”. In Lingala [language spoken in DRC, Congo, Angola and the Central African Republic], they call it “fufu”, but in my language, we call it kosa.

 

Do you eat this often, back in your country?

People eat it very often. It is a basic staple food. Nearly every dish is eaten with semolina, actually.

DSC_4706
Photo: Rex Yuen. Joseph, preparing the stew.

Is this a kind of famous dish in your country?

The famous dish in my country is called “koko”. In Hong Kong, we cannot find it. Koko is a kind of vegetable that is commonly available in Africa – but I have never seen it in Hong Kong.

 

Do you cook this stew often, since you’ve been in Hong Kong?

Yes, whenever I can, I cook it. With this sauce, we can make many different dishes, the sauce is good for fish too.

 

Is there a big African community – from your country of origin – in Hong Kong, that you feel a part of or are there not many people from your country here?

There is not too much, but we are around 9 or 10 from this country, here in Hong Kong. Because even in my country, we are not too many, only about 3 or 4 million and many just live in one of the big cities.

 

What would you like people to know about yourself and your country’s food?

You know, food is something good. When you don’t have food, you are nervous, you can die. Food is a basic thing that all people need – if you have good food, you have a good self. I think so. And if you don’t have your food when you like, you need to do something similar from your country.

 

How do you find Hong Kong?

Hong Kong is security, a secure city.

 

What is your everyday life like in Hong Kong? What do you do in a day?

Every day, especially if I don’t feel good, I run. You know, running is something people can do when they don’t feel good. You run and are able to de-stress. I like to run in the morning. And if I have nothing on, I go to the park and do training. Sometimes I come here [to the Refugee Union office], and I help out with the computers for the people here.

 

Did you work in IT or with computers before?

Yes. This is my background. This was my career before. But of course, I cannot work in Hong Kong as I am a refugee, so I help out with computers to pass the time.

 

If the government allowed you to work in Hong Kong, would you want to do this kind of job?

Yes. I could help many people.

 

 

[Editor’s note]: International charity Free to Run set up the running group a year ago, in collaboration with local NGO Justice Centre. Free to Run aims to use the power of sport to change lives and communities in areas of greatest need and co-ordinates running activities for refugees in Hong Kong. To find out more, this is their Facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/FreeToRunNGO/ 

The waiting game: 16 years in Hong Kong as a refugee

The waiting game: 16 years in Hong Kong as a refugee

As told to Leanne Ledgard. Words by Leanne Ledgard.

Mahmoud* arrived in Hong Kong more than sixteen years ago, after fleeing persecution in his country. Despite all his children being born and raised in Hong Kong, each day is uncertain, as Mahmoud cannot work to provide for his family – and his children live as stateless persons.

 

Would you mind telling me a bit about yourself? Where are you from?

I am from Pakistan.

 

And when did you come to Hong Kong?

2001.

 

What things would you like people to know about yourself?

I mean, what do people want to know about my situation? How I am suffering? I have been here since 2001. It is not a little amount of time. My children were born in Hong Kong. They do have birth certificates [showing they were born here], but they don’t have rights in Hong Kong for anything. I think it was a bad day, the day I made the decision to come to Hong Kong.

In many different countries… Europe, United States and Canada, it is possible to stay in these countries – I think for a few years. After five years, a person can see their case [for asylum heard], if they have not been given the right to stay already.

But in Hong Kong, since 2001, I have not been allowed to work. I have children. You would think that after 16 years right something would be done? I cannot work in Hong Kong and this is not a good life. I was young, but day by day, I’m getting old. I have my children, so what is their future?

People should know what is going on in Hong Kong. Like, my situation. Everybody has different case, different situation, different problem [being a refugee], its very hard in Hong Kong.

IMG_0814
Photo: Vlad Popov. 

 

Did you know much about Hong Kong before you came here?

Of course not. When I came in Hong Kong, it was my second time. But that moment, in the year I left, I went anywhere that would accept us for visa, it was urgent… like getting a passport, buying any ticket out of my country.

I decided to come Hong Kong although the moment [after the Handover] in 1997, everything changed. The British government moved from Hong Kong, but in my mind it was still the way [I remembered it]. We knew that Hong Kong was a British colony, but my own experience of this is only word of mouth.

But because the British left, they handed over to the Chinese, so it became a Chinese country. Sometimes I think if the British government was still here in HK, I don’t think that I would have stayed here for 16 and a half years waiting for my claim to be processed, without a job. I cannot work, it’s not legal. If I work, I could be punished (jailed) from two to 18 months, so who will take care of my children?

 

What do you think living in Hong Kong is like for you children?

I can say, they go to school, but there’s no future for them. They go to school, only to learn they lack status in Hong Kong. They were born here but they government in doesn’t accept them as nationals. Will they be given the right [of asylum] in HK? No.

 
What would like the public to know about your personal situation or the situation of other refugees?

Yes. I came to Hong Kong to make my children’s future, for their home. In my home country, and their mother’s home country, there is nothing. They have nowhere to go.

Welfare only give you food now, often rubbish food was given to refugees before. Now it is a little bit different because we have been struggling here for our rights for a long time. Since 2003 or 2004, these [welfare departments] have grown from 3 staff to 300 workers. They will get money for their work.

This is a business, it makes a business of refugees. They don’t want to make a decision. How can they support a client’s case then? When can something real happen? You don’t have to be like me, waiting 16 and a half years.

IMG_0784
Photo: Vlad Popov.

Are you hopeful, that you will get granted residency or you will be given an ID card?

You know, I have to have hope because in my home country, I am stateless. I was stripped of papers [that I used to have]. So here you can see my situation, only God can do something. He can move the mountains but I don’t believe in many people.

There is nothing here, nothing, nothing I can give, nothing good for my health, even the medicine they give me is very bad. But when you have back pain, head pain, liver problems, heart problems… They give you panadol! Because you are stateless. Seeking asylum in Hong Kong [means] mostly discrimination anywhere you go.

 

From local people, do you experience discrimination?

Yeah! Of course, even right now going to the agent of my apartment, I know they are lying to me. They hate or they don’t like refugees [and minorities]. Here it’s like an animal’s system. They don’t care! Don’t care who you are, what you are, what your problems are. We don’t know the laws of Hong Kong and it is very hard learning the language.

 

So, it’s hard to communicate with the locals?

Yes.


Shall we talk about your food a little bit?

Yeah, yeah,


What did you cook today?

I cook today, only a beef curry, another is the biryani and roti and another chicken.

 

Are these things that you would cook at home for your family?

Yes, at home, yeah.

 

Are they special dishes, or every day kind of things?

No, the biriyani you can see its special meal but not for every day. But beef curry and roti, we usually eat every day, for lunch. You eat at lunch with rice, with white rice, with vegetables, something like that.


And does it remind you of your home culture and country?

Yeah! always, yeah

 

Do you feel like people don’t listen to your story or that you have told it to a lot of people?

Everybody’s case is different. Some things you can share, some things you cannot share… it’s very hard. There are many legal issues as a refugee [filing a protection claim], so I cannot and mostly don’t share [my story], no.

Education is an alienable right, after all… if you are a child refugee in Hong Kong

Education is an alienable right, after all… if you are a child refugee in Hong Kong

By Tegan Smyth

Nino*, is a refugee from Togo. In 2005, he was forced to leave his country following a series of violent events which played out during a presidential election in his country.

He arrived in Hong Kong the same year, with only the clothes on his back. He has been in search of help for himself and his family ever since, however he feels the system has let refugees like him down. Although his two children were born in Hong Kong, they are denied the right of abode. Conservative estimates are that there at least 600 other children in the same predicament as Nino’s kids; born on Hong Kong soil but living as stateless persons.

IMG_20170314_215940
Photo: Tegan Smyth. A baby born in Hong Kong to a refugee mother.

“We need more support for the children. The government pays the school fees but not the books, uniform, shoes,” said Nino, when we spoke to him at Refugee Union.

Both of his children attend a local school in Hong Kong that requires them to pay HKD$914 per semester for books although other refugee children have had to pay up to HKD$1,500 per semester. Books are a prerequisite to attend their school – as is transportation – so access to education is not a guarantee for many refugee children.

Hong Kong’s current policy is to allocate an allowance to refugees, consisting of HKD$1,500 for rent, HKD$1,200 for food (in vouchers), HKD$200 for transport and HKD$300 for utilities each month. For refugee parents like Nino, this is falls far short of what is required to cover the remaining costs of his children’s education, especially since it is illegal for refugees to work while their asylum claims are being processed.

Over the past year, Nino has only been able to send his children to school, thanks to donations from Vision First, a local pastor and some individuals in the Hong Kong community. However, he does not feel this is a sustainable solution. Like many refugees, Nino believes that the no-work policy that is imposed on refugees makes it especially difficult for him to give his kids an education.

“Because refugees aren’t allowed to work, they can’t provide these basic things for their kids. In primary school, refugees manage to get some support but it’s not enough. I want to be able to buy a computer for my kid so that he can do his school work at home.”

During our interview, Nino’s kids are playing with a friend in the Refugee Union office. They are babbling in a mixture of English and Cantonese, as befitting their lives here, as the only place they have ever known is Hong Kong. Their carefree demeanour is in stark contrast with Nino’s, as the past twelve years for him have been of bare survival. His first seven months living in Hong Kong were marred by homelessness, he slept at Star Ferry pier with several other refugees.

IMG_20170325_204429_419(1)
Photo: Tegan Smyth. An uncertain future awaits this young girl in Hong Kong as her parents are still waiting for their claim to be processed.

Now he is one of the core coordinators of Refugee Union, a refugee-led society that was created to help refugees and asylum seekers in Hong Kong become more self-sufficient. He is involved in lobbying the Government and ISS, to give greater assistance to refugees in the city.  In the context of education for refugee children, it has been an uphill battle for Refugee Union and other advocacy groups to even get the government to recognise their children’s rights to education.

“Before, the government was paying half of the school fees. Because of Vision First [a local refugee/asylum seeker advocacy NGO], the government is now paying the full fees.”

In the meantime, he hopes that people are made aware of the predicament refugees and their children find themselves in.

“It is important that everyone in Hong Kong knows how refugees are living in Hong Kong, and the problems they are facing, so that something can be done to help,” he said.

At the forefront of his mind are his children and those of his peers. He hopes to build a future for them here, he fled political violence at home in the hope he could give his children a better life. Although Hong Kong enjoys greater political stability, families like Nino’s still find themselves in legal limbo. After more than a decade, his family’s refugee claim has still not been processed.

Despite Nino’s children growing up multi-lingual and calling Hong Kong their only home, they will remain excluded from the Hong Kong’s workforce and society, if the current policies prevail.

Lifting the ‘no-work’ policy and contrasting cultural values: Refugee Perspectives

Lifting the ‘no-work’ policy and contrasting cultural values: Refugee Perspectives

As told to Cynthia Chung

[Editor’s note] This is the third part of our interview with Alex* from Refugee Union. We spoke at length about the no-work policy, whereby refugees and asylum seekers are unable to work or volunteer by law. 

How would our society be different if the no-work policy is removed?

As I have said before, the millions of dollars that are currently being spent to support the refugees can be used on Hong Kongers themselves. When I walk around the streets of Hong Kong, I always meet very old people doing manual jobs. They are doing this due to lack of support from the government. Give them social welfare instead to help them meet their basic needs. I doubt you will ever see them again on the streets pushing loads of trash for sale.

DSC04614
Alex, preparing his dish. Photo: Matt Haslam.

There is also quite a number of very poor people in Hong Kong who can’t make ends meet, majority are as hungry as the refugees themselves. Use the HKD$600 million per year that you are currently giving to the refugees to uplift their living standards and better their lives. This would go a long way in reducing the huge wealth gap in Hong Kong. I guess that it is reasonable and noble to spend such huge amounts of money on its citizens rather than spending it on strangers that you really hate so much as to condemn them into this life of hopelessness. Mind you, the money is not enough now as it is, they need to go to the Legco again to request for extra money to meet the shortfall. How do you justify this?

Allowing refugees to work is the most responsible thing I can think of, they will start paying taxes just like everyone else, they will get back their human dignity that’s is so lacking at the moment. Give refugees back their human rights.

It will also lift off the burden of supporting refugees from the treasury and thereby direct the millions to other sectors of economy. This can also reduce the crime rate level. I have seen especially from the Chinese media how they demonize the refugee community alleging that they make Hong Kong less safe. Refugees are idle, they have nothing to do, if they were to start working, they will become productive people in the society. Crimes that they are committing are only a means of survival.

 

Refugees, of course, could offer many things to Hong Kong society.

Most of the refugees were professionals on their own in their countries of origin before they arrived in Hong Kong, they could add a lot of value to this city. Indeed they have the potential to help Hong Kong unleash its full potential that would move it to the next level of development through innovations. Currently refugees are wasting their lives lying idle day in day out, the government should make use them. They are untapped resource that can play a good role in this city.

With the nascent issues faced by students recently, there has been an onslaught of student suicides in recent months due to the pressure from the education system. Because you guys are from very diverse backgrounds, I feel like it would bring in a lot of new ideas and culture and better values. What do you think?

I think if you look at those societies that are very diverse they are stronger and cohesive, these societies also tend to grow faster, are very responsible and have a high sense of freedom.

I’m a bit surprised by what is happening in the local schools. I think it all goes back to your values and what you believe in. The value system of Chinese people is quite different from other peoples of the world. So are their way of life. These are the issues that are at play in the lives of their children. There is no diversity.

DSC04757
Photo: Matt Haslam.

I think that there is a misconception between good grades in school for example and work related environment. You can do very well in class but when you go out there and be employed you might not perform as exemplary as you did in a classroom.

So they should not focus on getting distinctions in their exams rather they should focus on a good education that prepares you well to handle challenges in life. Education should not be used as benchmark to measure success. Education should be used as the key to success, on learning and becoming educated one can then be in a position to unleash their full potential in life. Let the society lower the expectations that they shoulder on the young people. This way the pressure will go down from the students. As we speak the bar is very high, that’s not a conducive learning environment.

 

A lot of university students have been committing suicides, they work so hard to get into universities which are supposed to be a dream/ a place to meet ultimate happiness for them but they are still not happy when they achieve this. What are your thoughts?

What is your definition of happiness, what entails of one being happy. For me it’s making the best of what I have and thinking positively and how to move forward. Am happy when am healthy, I can afford to take good care of myself and my family. That’s what it means to be happy to me.

These kids are committing suicide due to pressure because the expectations for them is very high. The expectations reads like a business portfolio from a large multinational company. When it dawns on them that they might be unable to meet these expectations, then life stops having meaning, life becomes meaningless. When this happens they choose death.

Society has to think less of money because you don’t have to own billions to be happy. Nope. As long as you can make enough money to feed yourself, I think you are good to go. I do understand that in Hong Kong housing is a big issue, everybody wants a house and that’s okay. It should not be the problem that drives you crazy. That’s not a wish that is unique to Hong Kongers, everywhere in the world over people wants to own a decent home. But here, it borders on the extremes.

I think if you have enough money to eat, buy your clothes you should be happy. Don’t look at happiness as being able to drive a sleek Porsche or BMW as the only way to have a good life. That should not be it. Because you should define happiness in terms of being able to have a healthy body, be able to afford food, be able to buy yourself clothes, you don’t have to live in luxury to be happy. My advice to them is relook and maybe reevaluate your values, what you consider as important. Don’t focus too much on money. Do what you like to do, stay healthy, have good people and friends around you.

Get to know who your neighbors are, get to know them personally. Many of you do not even know them. You know in my country neighbors know each other very well. Here in Hong Kong people lead very individualistic lives, why is that? Cultivate communal culture, where everybody is responsible for each other.

 

What brings refugees together?

Culturally people tend to relate to each other. If you don’t know someone, you want to talk to that somebody and get to know them genuinely. You feel that you want to help each other, that’s the way I was brought up.

Everybody is important in a society, we are all equal. Everybody is your friend, you help and assist each other, and this brings about good relationships with other people. The society becomes cohesive.

That is not what happens around here, from what I see, people who live next door to you don’t even know you, yet you’re neighbors. If you have a problem, in my country, your neighbor is the first person to know. It’s someone you call when you have a problem. You go to that person, if you don’t have salt, you go to your neighbors and say “I don’t have salt” and they’ll give it to you. You know, people interact in a good and nice way. Of course, when you go to cities, people tend to live like they do here but it’s not even close.

In Hong Kong however, its way off, I can assure you, people don’t even care who lives next to you, what he or she does, you should be able to have neighbors who know each other who come together, who speak to each other, who share issues, you know. In the societies where I come from, African people are very communal, I think it’s because since time immemorial Africans lived in communal settings. Responsibilities were shared communally. Even though lifestyles have changed since colonization to the modern times, people still maintain those bonds to this day.

My guess as to why refugees stick together in Hong Kong is because one main reason only, they suffer discrimination and prejudice together. They understand the hardships of seeking safety in this city. And as the English men say, “birds of the same feather always flocks together”. It’s all about survival. They have realized that for them to make it here, they have to stick together as one.

From political violence to legal limbo: Refugee Perspectives

From political violence to legal limbo: Refugee Perspectives

(Continued from previous post)

As told to Mhairi McLaughlin and Tegan Smyth. Words by Mhairi McLaughlin. 

People in Hong Kong need to consider refugees as human beings, and understand that they need to be treated with the same respect as their own family

What is life like for your kids in Hong Kong? 

Nino: We need more support for the children. For kindergarten, the government pays the school fees but not the books, uniform, shoes etc. Because refugees aren’t allowed to work, they can’t provide these basic things for their kids. In primary school, refugees manage to get some support but it’s not enough. I want to be able to buy a computer for my kid so that he can do his school work at home.
Before, the government was paying half of the school fees. Because of Vision First, the government is now paying the full fees.

It is important that everyone in Hong Kong knows how refugees are living in Hong Kong, and the problems they are facing, so that something can be done to help. The media are useless – bar the alternative [non-mainstream] publications, the government has done all it can to stop the real stories being published.

Photo: Denis Tsoi. Close up of Veyi, a Togolese dish made from beans and cassava flour.

How did you first get involved in Vision First and Refugee Union?

I first met the people at Vision First in 2009, and decided to join them to help fight the system.

You do a lot of organising, in the past were you a teacher or a social worker? You are really involved with RU.

I’m not a politician, I was a simple guy who helped with the family property business. My grandparents used their own minds to set up a business and I followed them. When I came to Hong Kong in 2005, we didn’t have accommodation. We slept for 7 months on the Star Ferry Pier;  we had to hide ourselves from midnight to 6am because if the police found us they would tell us to leave because we weren’t allowed to sleep there.

Since 1967, the same political party has been in power in Togo, is this why most people have left?

My younger brother was a student leader campaigning for rights. In 2005 there was an election in our country and the police..they were the ones with control over the army, they took power from the ones who had won this election.

The students came out and protested for 45 days. As my brother was one of the leaders (there were five in total), one night these students leaders were all taken away.

I wanted to find out what happened to my brother. My mother, at the time, was also worried and was asking me and pushing me so I needed to find out what had happened to my brother.

I went to different government departments to find out where he was. I found out that on the same night he was arrested, he was killed. So when I pushed the government and spoke to the media one of the army chiefs called me.  He was a friend. He said: “We are the ones in power. Please leave. If you are at home, find a way to leave now.”

I just walked out for five minutes and saw a car driving out of my property. I came back and I could see my wife. They had beat her. She was two months pregnant at the time and lost the baby.

So you see how bad it was. But even now, the same people are in power. Nothing has changed.

Sometimes this all makes me feel bad, especially seeing all this anti refugee propaganda from the government. I’ve seen it all myself before – they don’t know what’s going on.

Photo: Matt Haslam.

When did things start getting better? Is your life better now?

Mark Daly, a human rights lawyer in Hong Kong, fought with the immigration department until taking the case to the media. In June 2006 the government started giving refugees accommodation. At that time they got HKD1000 for rent, HKD900 per month for food, and HKD10 for transportation.

We also receive food coupons which we can use at Park N Shop and Wellcome. This is great but the food is very expensive so this does not seem like the best solution.

Note from the writer: We apologise if some of the content featured in this article has been distressing. But it is important that you read it. 

Nino believes the Hong Kong immigration department uses refuges to make money for themselves. That these people are useless because the work they do to improve the quality of life of the refugees is completely disproportionate to their salary. They are pushing papers around, not knowing what it is to be a refugee with no money, yet at the end of the day they get paid and can go home to their families with food and a bed. 

Hong Kong immigration is creating separate departments to handle the cases of refugees because the justice system is so heavily influenced by politics. There is a continuous cycle of cases being rejected and refugees going back to appeal through hearings.

Living at society’s margins and below the poverty line: Refugee Perspectives

Living at society’s margins and below the poverty line: Refugee Perspectives

As told to Mhairi McLaughlin

In 2005, Nino* was forced to leave Togo as a result of political violence which played out during his country’s presidential election. He fled in search of help for himself and his family. 12 years later, he lives in Hong Kong with his wife and two children, still looking for help.

Do you enjoy living in Hong Kong?

Living here is not something you can enjoy. You start in the wrong place – the room that you have to sleep in is like living like an animal.

I arrived here in 2005 and in 2006 the government started giving accommodation to the refugees the room was tiny, just enough room for a bed. By the time my wife arrived with our two children in 2009, we were each allocated HK$1200 per month for rent. We managed to find a room on the 9th floor of a building. But my wife is anaemic, she struggled with the stairs and she still does now – over 10 years on and we’re all still there.

We started talking to the media about the tiny allowance we are given by the government and this helped us bit in being given more money for transportation – we were going crazy stuck in our room all day. As a human being you cannot stay in a room 24 hours a day – you need to be able to go out and see your friends. There is a constant worry about how we will pay for our rent as well. A friend used to help us out with money which meant we can afford our flat, but this friend has had to move away so again we will have to look for accommodation. But all we will be able to afford is a studio apartment  – how can 2 kids study in a studio apartment?

The refugee situation in Hong Kong is something which is very hard to compare. This is how we are treated by the government: if you are not Chinese, or if you don’t have money – forget being cared about.

Do you see any progression in the next 5 years? 

Not at all – the government will not raise our allowance but house prices will continue to rise. And the number of refugees in Hong Kong will grow and grow.

Right now there are around 15,000 refugees. After the Beijing Olympic Games in 2008, the number doubled because China kicked out the refugees and sent them in boats to Hong Kong. I think we can expect 20,000 refugees by 2020. Maybe more.

Photo: Tegan Smyth. Nino preparing a dish from his home country.

Where do most refugees live? 

Some live in slums, however refugees have started fighting about these slums (in NT e.g. Kam Tin) – these places are illegal and dangerous. This is the only place you can get a house if you are a refugee. If you have kids, and they are ill during the night for example , ambulances won’t come because it is so inaccessible. There are no basic amenities, schools, shops, hospitals. Either this they live under bridges, in the lobby of Chungking Mansions; they are homeless.

The worst part of it is that there is so much money in HK, but it is so unequally divided…

When you go to the International Social Service (ISS – who grant accommodation to refugees) they are not doing anything to help. They just help you to sign a contract, and then they get paid.

The government has a bad policy which punishes poor people – the immigration officers get paid a lot of money to help refugees but the refugees get almost no money. When you go to Skyline Tower in Kowloon Bay for your interview (to determine whether you can be categorised as a refugee), you are surrounded by an immigration officer, interpreter and a lawyer – all which cost so much money. You sit there for 6 or 7 hours while they ask you nonsense questions, going around in circles just so that they can say they have done the interview but in the end they don’t grant you refugee status.

The government has set up a mafia of people who take a lot of money to be allowed to do whatever they want. The government does not respect the taxpayers money.

How do we stop this happening? 

The best way forward is to tell the media, tell students and encourage change. So far the students have been given the wrong information.

A few years ago I made a programme with TVB news about our family being homeless and the day after the programme the government gave us enough money for a deposit for a flat. The government always try to cover up stories with money.

How about help from NGOs? 

I don’t believe that the NGOs [alone] help matters, because [some] do not treat the refugees correctly. They only help refugees so that they can get paid. They help you to prepare for your interview and then when the case is rejected, they don’t go to court to appeal with you. It’s half a job.

*name changed for confidentiality. Please note that views expressed are interviewees own.

A Policy for a Divided Society: How the No-Work Policy affects the livelihood of Refugees

A Policy for a Divided Society: How the No-Work Policy affects the livelihood of Refugees

As told to Cynthia Chung

Why is the no-work policy a problem to the refugee community?

Refugees in Hong Kong are not allowed to work to earn a living, they are barred by law from doing so.

We depend on the government welfare system (ISS) for survival. However, the welfare is grossly inadequate. It’s so low that it cannot meet our basic human needs.

Refugees are left to survive on their own without any how they manage within these boundaries of meager welfare assistance. They scavenge and beg to survive which puts them in a very difficult situation because it pushes the refugee community to the extreme margins of poverty.

As a result, refugees resort to other means in order to make ends meet. They have become the official suppliers of illegal labor, fueling Hong Kong’s underground informal economy which thrives through the cheap labor. Simultaneously, it exploits this marginalized, disadvantaged and vulnerable group of people in this great Asian city.

Other refugees engage in various vices such as prostitution, selling drugs and stealing for livelihood. For those who get caught by the police while working illegally, the punishment is so harsh that it’s better to be caught stealing or even selling drugs. They send you to prison for a 21 month sentence.

 

How do you help others overcome the problems that the no-work policy has bought to your community?

The Refugee Union advises the refugee community to follow the law and live on what is provided by the government because there’ll be indelible consequences. If you are caught working and sent to jail, you get a criminal record. This becomes a serious problem for you as you lose credibility.

A refugee who has a criminal record faces even more hardships, making it more difficult to get resettlement in a third country. Majority of countries will run a background check on you before accepting you. They try to find out what kind of person you are, and if you have a criminal record it reduces your chances of getting resettlement and a future, among other things.

The Refugee Union has always actively sought donors who are philanthropic enough to assist the refugee community with donations of various forms and kinds. May it be financial support, clothes, shoes, household items, furniture or even computers.  We welcome these kind donations in the forms or conditions that they are available. We then distribute these donations to members of our community.

We also liaise with Social Welfare Department to ensure that the welfare package prescribed by the government is accessible to all refugees. There are instances that Case workers from ISS Hong Kong gave less than what the Government promised by law, in this case we intervene to ensure that the law is enforced properly.

ISS Hong Kong does not give money directly to refugees, for housing refugees have to look for a house, sign a contract with the landlord then present the contract to ISS Hong Kong. ISS will then verify the validity of the contract and the ownership of the house before paying 1500 Hong Kong dollars directly to the landlords on monthly basis. Food is issued to us in the form of coupons [1200].

In the past, we used to get bags of food, which we would collect from selected stores across Hong Kong. These bags of food were not a good way of giving food to the refugees.

We were shortchanged by the system.

For example, the food was never fresh, with limited options while the amount given was always in dispute. We did not receive what was promised by law. This led to constant conflict with ISS case workers who declined to give us their price list that they were using to distribute the food. Refugees had to fight rigorously for an end to bags of food which saw the introduction of food coupons in mid of 2015. This fight was fought through a well thought out and deliberate campaign through protests, engaging the media and occupations that lasted over three months.

The use of food coupons does by itself pose challenges whenever we go out shopping, we are required to plan our purchases to 100 dollar coupons, it is indeed difficult for you to come up with items for a flat 100 dollar coupon, so most of the time you need to look for money to top up as you cannot get a balance from the coupon. Where do we get this money from?

16602151_1884158161830199_3863078800183478356_o
Photo: Refugee Union

How is it possible to survive on so little?

Basically it’s impossible to survive on 40 dollars a day in Hong Kong. You got to find ways to bridge the huge gap between what is provided to you to survive on and what you need in order to survive. Hong Kong is a very expensive city. How does the Social Welfare Department expect the refugees to survive off the current assistance?

We deduce that welfare is being used by the Government as a tool to manage/ suppress the refugee community. The strategy is to frustrate and force us to give up on our claims and rights so that we go back to our home countries. My take is that it has failed miserably to achieve that.

There are organizations as well as private individuals who donate both dry and ready to eat food to the Refugee Union. These food donations goes a long way in meeting our daily need while we hope that tomorrow will be a better day for us. For example we have an organization that gives us breads, cakes, sandwiches and salads every evening if they cannot sell all off their stocks for that day.

 

What are the consequences for companies if they are found out for hiring refugees?

The law says that an employer is breaking the law by employing a refugee to work for him, the individual concerned is liable to prosecution in a court of law. Punishment includes a fine of up to 50,000 Hong Kong dollars.

 

What is your opinion on the no-work policy in Hong Kong? How it should be changed?

 I think refugees should be allowed to work so that they can be able to support themselves. To me, the right to work is a human right.  If you deny someone the right to work, yet you do not meet his or her basic needs fully, that equals torture. Period.  This policy has changed industrious and hardworking people into pests.

They depend on others for survival. What a shame. This is not only a morally wrong but a very bad and inhumane policy decision.  Most of refugees are healthy and competent people, they can work and contribute to the development of Hong Kong society. The Government should focus on helping the senior citizens and the disabled with welfare instead of putting that money on the refugee community.

The hundreds of millions of dollars being used to fund the refugee lives here can be used to expand the social infrastructure in Hong Kong. Our lives have been ruined. We ran away from the risks of torture and death to a life of hopelessness in Hong Kong. Many of us now have become alcoholics as that’s the only meaningful thing one can do. You find that majority are always drunk because in the state of being drunk one tends to forget all your problems, we smoke weed, do drugs, all sorts of bad things that don’t add value to our lives or anyone else.  One wonders what are the cost benefit to Hong Kong in treating refugees in such an inhumane and cruel manner.

What happened to compassion and democracy? Are we truly honest with ourselves?  Surely Hong Kong can and should do better than this.

 

How do you overcome the bars no-work policy has set for you and how do you help people overcome them?

This is a law, it’s not easy to overcome a law that is so strictly enforced. I have not been able to overcome it. The only way to do it is to work illegally which is not an option for me. Refugee Union has not shied away from educating the public how discriminatory this law is to the lives of refugees. That’s why advocacy is our top priority as we engage the Government hoping to influence the policy makers to change their views about the refugee community.  We call upon all the loving people of Hong Kong to join us and demand that the law be changed as when some people are not free in a given society then all us will never be free.